World Cup: “There may be class contempt for the France group”


Lhe world of all controversies opens this Sunday in Qatar. Didier Deschamps’ band is placing their title on the road, gained 4 years in the past in Russia after a stifling last towards Croatia (4-2). The Blues, decimated by accidents, are removed from being the large favourites. Nonetheless, their entry into the competitors, Tuesday in Al-Wakrah towards Australia, arouses excessive expectations within the inhabitants.

François da Rocha Carneiro, historian specializing within the France group, creator ofA historical past of France in crampons (Editions Le Détour, 2022), recounts in an interview with Level the story of the bond that unites the French and the nationwide group.

Level : The French group is eagerly awaited in Qatar after its world title in Russia 4 years in the past. Since when has the nationwide group aroused such widespread curiosity?

Francois da Rocha Carneiro : We’ve to return to the Eighties. Shortly earlier than this era, the France group was fairly thought of the world champion in pleasant matches. She was superb at profitable when there was no stake. Every thing modified, nevertheless, in 1982, on the World Cup in Spain. The Blues, led by coach Michel Hidalgo and his captain Michel Platini, cross the towers and climb to the semi-finals. A feat. They may lastly bow to West Germany in a dramatized match as potential in Seville. Two years later, the Blues will find yourself profitable their first title, Euro 1984 organized in France.

So the true turning level is that this well-known Seville 82?

Completely, as a result of from Seville, the France group is lastly perceived as a group with the potential to win. There was definitely a feat in 1958 with a 3rd place on the World Cup organized in Sweden. However it’s kind of the tree that hides the forest: French soccer was not on the degree and particularly skilled the disaster within the Sixties. Quite a lot of work was then finished within the Seventies, particularly with the creation of a coaching system, to straighten out French soccer. That decade, the epic of AS Saint-Étienne within the European Cup contributed to the beginning of widespread curiosity in soccer. It was additionally presently that the French geared up themselves with increasingly more shade tv units, from which they may now comply with just a few matches of the Coupe de France and the France group.

READ ALSO“Nightmare of Seville”: we at all times redo the match

Ile-de-France residents invaded the Champs-Élysées after the world and European coronations of 1998, 2000 and 2018. This Parisian artery, alternatively, is way more sparse on Could 8, July 14 and November 11… French patriotism is expressed by soccer?

We have made a behavior of celebrating our footballing victories on the Champs-Élysées since AS Saint-Étienne celebrated their defeat within the 1976 Champions League last by descending the well-known Parisian thoroughfare. So I am unsure that we should always overinterpret the group results on victory nights as being the final word manifestation of patriotism. I imagine extra in an identification impact. Patriotism is the love of the nation of the fathers. However our French society could be very colourful, with folks having fathers from all over the place.

The France group displays this range. How do you clarify that many French folks of overseas origin choose the nationwide group of their mother and father’ nation to the France group?

I’ve simply mentioned it with my college students, a few of whom are involved. There may be an attachment that pushes them to idealize the nationwide group of their origins. This group, whether or not Portuguese, Algerian or in any other case, seems to be one of many final factors of attachment to the nation of origin. This doesn’t imply that they don’t assist, furthermore, the France group.

READ ALSOFebruary 15, 1931. The day the primary black joined the French soccer group

Why are some gamers blamed for not singing The Marseillaise ?

The story dates again to 1996. Throughout a political rally, Jean-Marie Le Pen pointed to the gamers of the France group, taking over the arguments of the far-right press of the Nineteen Thirties. mercenaries and reproached them for his or her cosmopolitanism. The president of the Nationwide Entrance provides – as proof – that some gamers don’t sing the nationwide anthem. He interprets this as an indication of an absence of affection for France on the a part of folks purported to defend his jersey.

Since this controversy fomented by Jean-Marie Le Pen, gamers are strongly inspired to sing the nationwide anthem. In 2010, coach Laurent Blanc, after the South African scandal of the Domenech period, even had the phrases of the Marseillaise distributed to his gamers… However, nobody is offended when athletes from different disciplines stay silent . Who remembers that three of the 4 French riders who had been Olympic present leaping champions in 2016 didn’t take up the nationwide anthem broadcast after the medal ceremony?

There are two weights, two measures…

Positive. French footballers are significantly identified as a result of lots of them have a former French colony as their nation of origin. France has extra to settle its colonial previous than the gamers must show by this tune their adherence to France.

After the strike of the Blues in Knysna in South Africa through the 2010 World Cup, public opinion shouted down its nationwide gamers. In 1998 and 2000, she celebrated them as heroes. In soccer, can we additionally go from like to hate?

Most likely sure. Above all, it reveals that the group might be versatile… particularly if given the chance. The sports activities press utilized to hate Raymond Domenech, the coach of the time. The political world of the Nicolas Sarkozy years took benefit of the controversy to gas the controversy on nationwide identification. Pure ideology.

READ ALSOWorld Cup 2018: how presidents turned soccer followers

A part of public opinion expects a symbolic gesture of assist from the Blues for migrant staff in Qatar and LGBT folks. Is that this their function?

Beneath the pretext that they’re on TV, they’re required to make the best political speeches and the best societal and environmental sensitivities… They’ve determined to assist NGOs. This is perhaps lead.

Why does every thing associated to the France group develop into so shortly controversial?

The France group is a big sounding board, on the one hand, and there’s a type of class contempt, on the opposite.

How is that this class contempt characterised?

An instance: the actor Vincent Lindon known as for a boycott of the World Cup organized in Qatar. Why not ! Human rights are usually not revered and this competitors is a climatic aberration. Nonetheless, did this identical Vincent Lindon, president of the jury of the Cannes Movie Pageant 2022, name for a boycott of the movies produced by the Doha Movie Institute in competitors at Un sure regard and La fortnight of administrators? Reply: no. Cinema is an artwork, you see? Requires a boycott of the World Driving Championships in Doha and the Method 1 Grand Prix in Qatar are additionally uncommon… Why? As a result of these sports activities are adopted, for probably the most half, by a sure social elite.

This contempt can also be characterised by cash…

Sure, all of us bear in mind this sentence from Anne-Sophie Lapix on the “millionaires” who “run after a ball” on the daybreak of the 2018 World Cup in Russia. We do not blame the youngsters of millionaires for being millionaires too. So why are youngsters from the suburbs blamed for it? Extra class contempt. Changing into an expert footballer entails nice sacrifices, from an early age. Additionally it is way more tough to combine the French group than to enter Regular Sup. The statistics are formal! There may be an immense “proletarian” mass amongst skilled gamers.


Leave a Comment