May soccer ever lose its thoughts?

The numerous “headbutts” given by a participant throughout his profession signify a hazard to his well being. A documentary highlights this drawback, which is little talked about in France.





By Adrian Mathieu

It is exhausting to think about at some point Varane depriving himself of his aerial sport.
© Jean Catuffe/DPPI through AFP

I subscribe to 1€ the first month


EWhat if we have been on the verge of a revolution in soccer, with the pure and easy ban on taking part in with the top? If the reflection could appear far-fetched at this time, on this sector which issues rather a lot to the gamers, specifically with a view to make variations on set items, a documentary has determined to place this delicate topic on the entrance of the stage.

Produced by The Crew, headless soccer relies on quite a few testimonies from gamers, coaches and in addition medical doctors to indicate that extreme head-butting can have severe penalties: gamers who’ve carried out a really giant variety of them throughout their profession can be inclined to mind illness.

“Greater than 1,000 former gamers identified with issues”

Considered one of its administrators, Frédéric Roullier, returned for Level on his method and his need to see the world of soccer within the face of this potential main well being drawback. “It was a world reflection, I took an interest on this query after seeing the ban on heads for younger individuals in Britain and america. »

Certainly, on the opposite aspect of the Atlantic and in our British neighbours, headers are prohibited for gamers beneath the age of 10 and 12 respectively. “Docs and well being research have confirmed our intuitions,” continues Frédéric Roullier. We wished to inform this phenomenon with out it being too technical by additionally counting on individuals who can convey this message, like Éric Carrière. »

The cameras thus observe the 2001 French champion with Nantes present process mind MRIs to confirm whether or not his a few years of getting to battle to take the ball from the top have had penalties on his cerebral capacities. Its outcomes will likely be identified subsequent yr. The documentary additionally provides the ground to the youngsters of the gamers of the legendary England group that received the World Cup in 1966.

A number of of them had severe after-effects, linked to their repeated headbutts. “It’s a must to think about what these households are going via,” says Frédéric Roullier. We uncover that these instances are increasingly quite a few: greater than 1,000 former gamers identified with issues. Nobby Stiles’ son [joueur emblématique de Manchester United, NDLR] recounts the very delicate finish of lifetime of his father, who now not acknowledged anybody. It is each very shifting and on the identical time the individuals involved are saying “let’s use our story to make it a warning cry for others” with a view to set off one thing. »

Researchers have already warned

If the Anglo-Saxons take this drawback very critically, for the second, in France, no safety measure has been taken. A research performed by researchers on the College of Glasgow (Scotland), in 2019, nonetheless, indicated that footballers are 3.5 occasions extra more likely to die from a neurological pathology than the remainder of the inhabitants. “The coaching could possibly be reoriented on different facets,” says the director. Whenever you’re younger, you do not but have the appropriate approach to hit the ball along with your head. The much less you grasp this gesture, the extra well being dangers you’ve gotten. Why not begin with foam balloons? »

Questioned within the documentary, the medical director of the FFF, Emmanuel Orhant, claims to concentrate on the varied research which alert on the topic. He signifies {that a} reflection exists on this hazard and that the Federation plans to maneuver the traces from subsequent season. UEFA can be conscious of this drawback and would contemplate proposing Europe-wide laws.

READ ALSOWorld Cup – Our choice of books for the competitors

However, it’s troublesome to make the principle involved hearken to cause on this potential change, which might utterly shake up the apply of the most well-liked sport on this planet. “The world of soccer could be very closed. It’s inconceivable for a big a part of the audio system to ban the heads, they utterly ignore this hazard which awaits them. I actually have been taking part in soccer for thirty years, I’ve completely nothing in opposition to the game! However we now have to ask ourselves the appropriate questions: we now have this invisible risk hovering above us, ”analyzes Frédéric Roullier.

“Un soccer sans tête”, a documentary by L’Équipe, directed by Frédéric Roullier and Fabien Duflos.


Leave a Comment